Mi Casa, Su Casa | Chomp | Testosterone Tasks | Vim & Vigor | Gear | Refer-A-Friend
Check out the new book! | Porch Talk | Cash Money | Emil Post | Show Off


more porch talk
» When Harry Weds Sammy!
» Love Defined
» Turn Off Your Tube
» Passion's Controversy
» Skinny At Any Expense

» porch talk archives

Controversy Over The Passion
By Melissa King
Intro | Jews and Christians | The Affect

What Jews Have Gone Through
It saddens me that my Jewish friends don’t understand something that for me is so central to my faith. But the more I spoke with people from the Jewish community, I could see that their anger and misunderstanding was justified. The New York Times recently published an open letter to Mel Gibson from Sue Perlman, a Jew and a professed Christian. The letter explained, “over the years, many so-called "Christians" have blamed my Jewish people for Jesus' death. The hatred and persecution we've endured as a result is tragic, and that's made some Jews very defensive when it comes to the subject of the Passion.” Dennis Prager paints the picture even brighter “…for nearly 2000 years, attacked as “Christ-killers,” countless Jewish men, women and children were tortured and murdered in ways that often caused more suffering than even Jesus endured (e.g., not only tortured and murdered themselves, but also seeing their families and friends raped, tortured and murdered). For Jews to worry that a major movie made by one of the world’s superstars depicts Jews as having Christ tortured and killed might arouse anti-Semitic passions is not paranoid.”

Why Christians Don’t Understand
Wow! I was struck by that statement. I had no idea that Jews had experienced that kind of persecution from people who claimed to be Christians. Any so-called believer who is anti-Semitic has absolutely no understanding of what Christianity and Jesus are about.

Having only spent three years of my life in New York City, a place rich with cultural diversity and where exposure to others of all types of beliefs is inevitable, my mind has been opened in ways I never expected. I grew up on a farm in the Midwest and spent more than half of my adult life in the South. In places like these, you are either a Christian or not a Christian. There are few people who practice other faiths, and those who are practicing another faith tend to keep to themselves. Most Christians in this country really have no idea how a film like The Passion, a story of faith, hope and love, could ignite so much anger and misunderstanding. They have had little opportunity to interact with the people being affected. For them, for us, it truly is about the sin of the human race. It’s about us all, no one sect of people. Most Christians would point their finger at themselves as the one to blame for Christ’s death before they will point it at anyone else.

next >



tell it to the 'tat

Have you got a bee in your political bonnet? Write it up. Let us know. Submit an article, an idea or a plain old question. From healthcare reform to school vouchers to permit parking; we want to hear about it. Let the cohabitation begin.